A real year. A real story.
A genuine penny turns a birthday, anniversary, new beginning, or family story into something small enough to carry every day.
Personalize on Etsy ↗100,000+ Etsy sales20,000+ reviewsMade in Oregon
Stamped one letter at a timeMade for a real story
Browse a focused selection here, then choose your options and enter personalization securely through our established Etsy shop.
Steel · Brass
A great gift for a loved one! This keychain features a heart charm with your choice of word, like Dad, Dada, Daddy etc. Add as many penny charms as…
Choose: Heart and Penny Charms
Stainless steel · Bronze
A great gift for a loved one! This keychain features a heart charm with your choice of word, like Mom, Momma, Mommy, etc. Add as many penny charms as…
Choose: Penny and Heart Charms
Steel · Brass
A great gift for a loved one! This keychain features a disc charm with your choice of word, like Dad, Dada, Daddy etc. Add as many penny charms as…
Choose: Heart and Penny Charms
copper penny · key ring
Make this into a great gift for a loved one!
US Penny · Aluminum Charm
A great gift for a loved one! Great for an aluminum 10 year anniversary! Add your names on a 1" circle charm and your anniversary date on the penny.…
Choose: Disc Charm Metal
copper penny · key ring
Make this into a great gift for a loved one! Personalize this penny with your sobriety date. Heart will be around the penny year of your choice.…
Stainless steel · Rose gold
Make this into a great gift for a loved one!
copper penny · key ring
Make this into a great gift for a loved one!
Penny · Brass
A great gift for a loved one! This brass keychain features the phrase “21 Years and Counting" on a 1" disc charm and a penny stacked on top. Your…
Choose: Penny Year
Penny · Aluminum
A great gift for a loved one! This aluminum keychain features the phrase “(10) Years and Counting" on a 1" disc charm and a penny stacked on top.…
Choose: Penny Year
Brass · Stainless steel
A great gift for a loved one! “Still Yours” will be stamped on the disc charm. Penny has your initials stamped on it. A heart is stamped around the…
Penny Charm · Keyring
A great gift for a loved one! This keychain features a penny charms with your choice of city or country! commemorate your trips with pennies from…
Choose: Heart and Penny Charms
A recent five-star Etsy review
“These pennies were a HUGE HIT for Father's Day! What a beautiful, simple way to have a daily reminder of those we love so much!”
Judy · Etsy review · June 2026
Personalized by hand